CometBFT allows a malicious peer to make node stuck in blocksync

QFinch assessment

Name: ASA-2025-001: Malicious peer can disrupt node's ability to sync via blocksync Component: CometBFT [OUTDATED] Criticality: Medium (Considerable Impact; Possible Likelihood per [ACMv1.2](https://github.com/interchainio/security/blob/main/resources/CLASSIFICATION_MATRIX.md)) **Update of Criticality on 2026-03-06**: We've made a mistake and over-rated the criticality of this bug in our initial triage. We have calibrated our vulnerability rating internally and updated the criticality of this bug to be Informational (Negligible Impact, Possible Likelihood) Affected versions: <= v0.38.16, v1.0.0 Affected users: Validators, Full nodes

Potential impact

A malicious peer may be able to interfere with a node's ability to sync blocks with peers via the blocksync mechanism. In the blocksync protocol peers send their base and latest heights when they connect to a new node (A), which is syncing to the tip of a network. base acts as a lower ground and informs A that the peer only has blocks starting from height base. latest height informs A about the latest block in a network. Normally, nodes would only report increasing heights: If B fails to provide the latest block, B is removed and the latest height (target height) is recalculated based on other nodes latest heights. The existing code hovewer doesn't check for the case where B first reports latest height X and immediately after height Y, where X > Y. For example: A will be trying to catch up to 2000 indefinitely. Even if B disconnects, the latest height (target height) won't be recalculated because A "doesn't know where 2000" came from per see. Impact Qualification This condition requires the introduction of malicious code in the full node first reporting a non-existing latest height, then reporting lower latest height and nodes which are syncing using blocksync protocol.